Wednesday, 23 March 2016

Why Republicans shouldn't fear an Independent Trump

The United States Presidential election has thus far, not only not only defied conventional wisdom, but rather beaten it senseless, and then some. Republican frontrunner, the real estate mogul and star of numerous reality tv shows Donald J. Trump, has broken every political rule in the book. He has insulted Latinos, Blacks, Muslims, Women (really the majority of Americans), with statements that would make Marine Le Pen blush. He has incited violence, promoted bigotry, and come across as uninformed and ignorant, with a temperament that would be more suited to WWE than the White House. Yet staggeringly, his numbers have only gone up. He now seems certain to head into the Republican convention in Cleveland this June, having wrapped up the nomination, or at the very least fallen just a few delegates short.

Realistically, the only chance Mr Trump has of not winning the nomination is via a brokered convention. In such a case, the popular vote would largely be thrown out thrown out the window, and the party establishment would decide who to nominate, likely either Governor Kasich of Ohio, or Paul Ryan, current Speaker of the House. If he is ‘robbed’ of the nominated in such a way, Mr Trump has threatened riots, and to turn his back on the party and run as an independent, taking his huge grassroots support with him. Such a situation terrifies Republican commentators, who agree that it would almost certainly hand Hilary Clinton the presidency. However, such fears are largely overblown, and an independent Trump is unlikely to hinder a Republican campaign, for three key reasons.

First, Mr Trump’s popularity with voters has been overestimated. Although he is coming first, and has been doing so for a while, this is largely the fault of an overly crowded Republican field, which at one stage consisted of 18 different candidates. They spent so much time attacking each other that they largely ignored Trump, expecting him to fizzle out. In addition, while there have been record breaking turnouts at primaries, a crucial fact remains; Mr Trump has never exceeded more than 50% of the vote. With over half the states now called, and the field reduced to just 3 remaining candidates, this is simply put, quite staggering. This means that, at these recording-breaking primaries, the majority of Republicans are voting against Trump, and for a separate candidate. With Trump having insulted so many of his rivals, from Bush, Cruz, Rubio and Fiorina, in deeply vitriolic attacks, winning over their support will provide Trump with an enormous mountain to climb.

Secondly, despite constantly flaunting his wealth, and claiming that because of it, ‘’he cannot be bought’’, Trump has largely avoided spending any of his own money on his campaign. Instead, he has relied on free coverage from the media, granted everytime he says something particularly despicable. In November for example, when it seemed that his momentum had stalled and he had been overtaken by Ben Carson in the polls, he proposed banning all Muslims from entering the United States. This led to a huge increase in coverage and, consequently, he regained his frontrunner status. It is unclear how much of his own money he would be willing to spend on what would certainly be a doomed independent presidential bid, and he will find the media less attentive, as they focus on the two main parties. Thus, an independent Trump candidacy may not even materialise.

Finally, and perhaps most importantly, the reason that grassroots republicans support Trump in such high numbers is because they are angry. The U.S. is becoming a multi-racial majority country, and poor whites feel like they have lost out. Trump provides them a voice, as belligerent as it may be, and is also incredibly politically incorrect, for which they love him even more. But despite a media consensus, to portray them all as idiots is to do them a disservice. They know that by voting for an independent Trump in the General, they will be handing the presidency to Hilary on a silver platter. And that’s the key. For as much as they hate the Republican establishment, they hate Hilary and Democrats even more, and will do anything in their power to stop her.


If Trump wins enough pledged delegates in time for the convention, then all of this is largely moot. However, if he does not, Republicans should not be afraid to turn their backs on him, and hand the nomination to someone else. This will give them a much greater chance of retaining both the House and the Senate, and more importantly, of taking back the White House

No comments:

Post a Comment